Author: Jan Anschuetz
In the Spring 2014 issue of the Gleanings we met Mark and Roccena Vail
Norris who were described as the “parents of Depot Town.” They were also the parents of two
children: Elvira and Lyman Decatur. In this installment of “The River Street Saga” we will
learn more about Elvira, her life, her family (including her amazing husband, Benjamin Follett), and
their own influence on the growing town of Ypsilanti in the nineteenth century.
We can only imagine the challenging life of Elvira, who was born in a log cabin on January 22,
1821 in Covington, New York. When she was only seven years old, the Norris family made the grueling
trip from New York State to a sparsely settled wilderness lacking any degree of civilization – a
place without a church, organized town council, roads, mills, or even a name. Mark and Roccena soon
helped to change that and contributed greatly to making Ypsilanti a community in which people wanted
to live - complete with a town organization, a railroad, laws, schools, churches, cultural
opportunities, a library, stores, mills, and beautiful homes.
For the first year of their arrival, the Norris family lived behind a storefront at what is now
the southwest corner of Michigan Avenue and Washington Street. This cramped space did not stop
Elvira’s mother from teaching children of the settlement in one of the four rooms that the family
shared. Roccena was dismayed that there was no place for religious instruction or worship and
quickly organized a Sunday School for all ages that met in a log cabin each week and would also
welcome circuit riders to preach when possible. The Norris home was always available to offer
hospitality to visiting preachers.
The following year, the small family was able to move into the first sawn wood-frame home east of
the Huron River, and within a few years was living in a brick mansion which was originally built for
Roccena’s uncle. When her uncle was unable to move into it, Mark and Roccena purchased the
unfinished structure from him for $1,000. It was in this eight bedroom mini-mansion on River Street
that Elvira and her brother spent their childhood. Aside from the years 1834 to 1836 when she
attended a celebrated all girls finishing school in Detroit, Elvira received her entire education in
Elvira grew up accustomed to fine gowns, a beautiful home complete with gardens, and indulgent
parents. She had friends, a church community, and charitable activities to keep her occupied, and
enjoyed the status of being a part of one of the wealthiest families in Washtenaw County due to her
father’s ambition and hard work. She was brought up to cherish reading and education and the
finer things in life. Her brother spoke of Elvira’s education in a life sketch he prepared for
Elvira’s funeral. Speaking of his own childhood home on River Street he stated “…the
pioneer home was perhaps a better school for life and its duties than most of our modern young
ladies’ seminaries. In that home, heart, mind and soul were trained into symmetry and strength.
That hospitable roof sheltered more than one guest, from which the family gained more than they
gave. The ‘prophet’s chamber’ was seldom vacant in their day, when the traveler was forced to
rely upon private hospitality for entertainment by the way, and the growing girl may have learned
much of that breadth of broad-gauge sympathy with all classes and conditions, which she displayed in
later years, from this contact with the men and women of many types, which the exigencies of those
pioneer times brought to the door.”
Mark Norris, Elvira’s father, was from a large family with 14 children and many of Elvira’s
uncles and aunts on both sides of her family moved into the community. One of her uncles, Justus
Norris, who lived nearby and ran her father’s Western Hotel on River Street, was a noted and
outspoken abolitionist in Washtenaw County. More will be written about him in another segment of
“The River Street Saga.”
Elvira’s maternal grandmother moved from New York State to enjoy living on the Huron River in
their fine house. It was not unusual for Elvira and her mother to travel back to New York by train
or ship to visit family there or to enjoy some of the “cures” offered at that time in various
spas. On one such trip, she arrived home at the train station in Depot Town only to have her father
meet his beloved wife and daughter in a beautiful new carriage pulled by two matching and elegant
horses which delivered them to the family home one block away. There, another surprise awaited
them - a new grand piano in the parlor.
You might imagine that it would be difficult for a young woman brought up in luxury to find a
suitable husband in the frontier town of Ypsilanti, but somehow the right man was waiting for her,
living only a few blocks away. Benjamin Follett, who would wed Elvira, seemed the perfect match.
He too had been born in New York State, where his father had been a store owner as had Elvira’s
father when they lived in New York. Benjamin’s parents were Nathan and Nancy Keith Follett.
Prior to marrying Nathan, Nancy Keith was a young widow with two children of her own. When they were
married in Canandaigua, New York in 1818, the young couple was admired for their handsome
appearance. Benjamin was born the next year in 1819.
Nathan owned a hat store and was also a successful businessman. The family lived in Batavia, New
York, and was comprised of Benjamin (who was the oldest) along with Nancy Keith’s two children
from her first marriage. In a family paper written by Roy K. Spencer, we learn that Nathan built a
hat factory and was also a banker. “For many years he was one of Batavia’s most prominent
citizens. He was repeatedly elected to the most important posts in Batavia’s village government,
he was vestryman of the Episcopal Church, and he became one of the wealthiest men in
Benjamin grew up in a large and luxurious home with servants, some of whom were once slaves on
the Virginian plantation on which his mother grew up. His mother and father were adamant
abolitionists and when they inherited the plantation they freed the slaves, sold the property, and
moved north to a state that did not allow slavery. Some of their former slaves moved with them and
became paid servants. We read that Benjamin’s childhood home was always filled with the pets that
his father Nathan loved including dogs, cats and birds. Sadly, this happy family life came to an
end with the death of a child in infancy and the death of Nathan’s young and beautiful wife.
Nathan married again a few years later to a first cousin and they had three more children before she
Perhaps because of an anti-Mason sentiment in New York at the time, or perhaps because Benjamin
simply wanted to “go west and seek his fortune” as many young men were advised to do, he arrived
in Ypsilanti as a young man. We do know that Benjamin Follett was first mentioned in the written
history of Ypsilanti at the age of 19, in the year 1836. At that time he was employed as a cashier
for the Bank of Ypsilanti. In T. H. Rinchman’s book Banks and Banking in Michigan with
Historical Sketches, published in 1887, Follett is described as “a worthy, conscientious
and competent young banker.”
Mark Norris was a major stock holder in the Bank of Ypsilanti and we can only guess that Mark and
Roccena invited this eligible young bachelor with a good character, family, and prospects into their
home to meet their young daughter from a similar background. We do know that by 1841, after the
failure of the Bank of Ypsilanti in the “Wildcat Schemes” of the time, Benjamin had returned to
Batavia, New York to work as a bank cashier and to be closer to his family. It was there that he
sent for and married Elvira on September 23, 1841. The young couple lived in that community for two
years even though Elvira missed her family and friends in Ypsilanti. Letters from her father found
in the Ypsilanti Historical Museum archives, which counseled her to try to make the best of her new
community and to always speak positively of the people of Batavia, seem to suggest that Elvira was
not happy living away from her River Street home.
It seems that Mark and Roccena also missed the company of their daughter and Mark might have
influenced their return to Ypsilanti by offering his son-in-law partnership in a mill. Perhaps the
“icing on the cake” was building and gifting them a spacious, elegant, and charming new home on
the east side of River Street, between Oak and Maple Streets, just three blocks away from Elvira’s
childhood home. In 1843, after two years in New York, the young couple returned home. We read in
Sister Maria Hayda’s book The Urban Dimension and the Midwestern Frontier, A Study of
Democracy at Ypsilanti Michigan, 1825-1858 that “Benjamin Follett possessed relatively
large amounts of capital from his own family resources in New York” which he was ready to
invest in Ypsilanti. In fact, tax records from the 1850 federal census cite him as owning $27,000
worth of real estate and he was estimated to be the fifth wealthiest citizen in town.
The partnership with his father-in-law sharing the ownership of a mill did not work out. It
seems that Benjamin was not a successful miller and within a few years had returned to banking and
financing. He also spent time and energy investing in railroads, building and running a fine hotel,
investing in a store, two mills, and other ventures. Benjamin had a gift for leadership and soon
became a pillar of Ypsilanti life, influencing its development. Like his father before him, he
believed in giving back to the community and sharing his time for the good of the people of the
growing town. In 1860, Benjamin was elected Ypsilanti’s third mayor. As such, he helped to
organize the first fire department and paid for the fire equipment out of his own money. Later he
served on the city council and was active in the Democratic Party. He was an active member of St.
Luke’s parish and served on the building committee for a new church. Benjamin partnered in a land
deal which added a vast amount of area to the city of Ypsilanti. He influenced city leaders into
building the first city hall and jail on Cross Street on the east side near Depot Town. Benjamin was
one of the founding members of the Masonic Wyandotte Lodge Number 10, and built their headquarters
in what is now known as the three-story Masonic Block on Cross Street in Depot Town.
Benjamin invested heavily in the growing Depot Town area by financing and building a lavish hotel
in 1859 which is still standing and bears his name as The Follett Block. Not only that, but this
amazing, energetic, and imaginative man also organized and led a choir which regularly sang and
entertained the community in Follett Hall located in the building. His business interests extended
to the Peninsular Paper Company, the Farmer’s General Store, the Eagle Mill, the Huron Mill, as
well as other business undertakings.
Benjamin’s father Nathan moved to Ypsilanti in the year 1849. Nathan was only 50 years old at
the time of his second wife’s death. He had 5 children to raise alone and his financial status,
as well as his personal life in New York State, quickly nose-dived when three friends for which he
had signed promissory notes defaulted. That left Nathan responsible for their debts, which amounted
to a large sum of money. Spencer tells us that “saddened by the death of his wife and
disillusioned by the conduct of his alleged friends, he packed his furniture into a railroad freight
car, took his numerous family, consisting of his four daughters and the two children of Nancy, whose
husband had died a few years after marriage to settle in Ypsilanti, Michigan, where his son,
Benjamin, was an active and successful citizen.” Nathan also brought four or five servants with
him but they soon tired of the “wild west” of Ypsilanti and returned to the “more civilized”
Nathan was able to reclaim his role as a community leader in his new town of Ypsilanti. He
purchased the stone house across from the Quirk mansion on North Huron Street and had enough capital
to buy and run two successful flour mills in town. He joined his son Benjamin in becoming an active
member of the Episcopal Church and was remembered as a man who, like his son, lived his Christian
religion with kind regard for all. An example of this was his interest in the education and
promotion of a young black man, John Fox. Nathan hired him to do minor clerical work but paid him
well enough so that he was able to study law and be admitted to the bar. Indeed, this liberal
attitude that all people were equal seemed to be extended to his son Benjamin who was rumored to aid
While Benjamin, his father, and father-in-law were busy making money as the town of Ypsilanti
expanded, Benjamin and Elvira’s family expanded as well. They had seven children, five sons and
two daughters, to fill their large home and their hearts. The oldest daughter, Alice, was born in
1844. Another daughter, Lucy Elvira, followed in 1847. A son, Nathan, was born in 1849 and another
boy, Lyman Decatur, in 1851. Benjamin was born in 1854. Mark Norris was born in 1858 and his
brother Simeon Keith, born in 1860, completed the family.
Elvira’s widowed aunt, Mrs. Blackmon, sister of her mother, came to live with the family soon
after they moved into their River Street home and became a second mother to the children. Lyman
Norris tells us “For thirty years this good aunt remained with them, leaving this home only for an
eternal one. During all these years, she bestowed upon Mrs. Follett and her children all the love
and care of her motherly heart. Her presence made it possible for Mrs. Follett to enter more into
outside affairs than she could otherwise have done; to take many journeys, longer and shorter, with
her husband; and to assist him more freely in that large hospitality which he so enjoyed.”
A photograph of happy children, dogs, flowers, grass, and a fountain in front of their charming
house on River Street gives us the impression that Elvira and Benjamin were well rewarded for their
work ethic. In The History of Ypsilanti, written in 1923 by Harvey Colburn, this River
Street mansion is described as follows: “The beautiful Follett home was for years one of the
show places of the city. It was situated on River Street in a grove of oak trees extending from Oak
Street to Maple, a great rambling structure with big bay windows. The surrounding grounds were
extensive, brilliant with flowers, and adorned by a large fountain fed by a windmill standing on the
hill above.” The home was the first in Ypsilanti illuminated by gas lights. People came
from miles around just to admire the barn which was considered one of the finest in Michigan, if not
in the country.
Benjamin and Elvira, though busy with their family and life in Ypsilanti, also enjoyed traveling.
In 1853 the young couple, along with her parents and brother, took a vacation which included
visiting Montreal, Bellows Falls, New Haven and New York. In her letters we read that Elvira
thought that traveling and adventure were important to further her education and life views. She
was also interested in a healthy life style and one of her favorite excursions was to visit the
water cure at Elmira, New York, sometimes staying there for several months. Her youngest two
children were born there.
Elvira also had a serious side. Like her mother, she was dedicated to helping to improve the
community. She was a life-long member of The Home Association, which she helped to organize in 1857
and later served on the board and as an officer. This was a group of women from various churches,
who attempted to make the lives of the poor and destitute of the community better in any way that
they could – providing food, transportation, clothes, and even firewood.
For many years she was one of the vice-presidents of the Detroit Home for the Friendless and her
organizational and interpersonal skills helped to form the agency and its policies. She shared her
mother’s love of reading and was the first president of The Ypsilanti Ladies’ Library
Association. Her brother commented that “the influence of this valuable Library Association
upon the mental growth and culture of the town has been very great; and she was one of the most
indefatigable of the body of intelligent, cultured women, to whose labors the library owes its
Alas, the lives of this energetic, active, happy, and productive couple changed. First
Elvira’s father Mark Norris died in 1862 after an extended and painful illness. The next year, in
1863, his namesake, their six year old son, Mark Norris Follett, died suddenly of diphtheria. After
that, things only seemed to get worse. Benjamin Follett was one of the founders of the beautiful
Highland Cemetery on River Street which was dedicated in 1864. Little did he know that only four
months after making one of the speeches at the opening ceremony, he, himself would be buried there.
It seems that he attended the Democratic National Convention in Chicago, leaving in good health and
then on September 1st he was stricken with coughing and hemorrhaging of the lungs and conveyed back
to his River Street home and family. In a letter written to her grandmother in late 1864, daughter
Alice stated “Father gains very slowly and coughs a good deal. Dr. (sic) was here and
insisted there is no tubercular disease of the lungs. He does not want him to go away for all
winter but wants him to visit and be away from all worrying business. It seems very slow and
discouraging.” Benjamin and Elvira followed the doctor’s orders and left for the water
cures they had often taken at Elmira, New York. The night before they left they gathered their
family around them in prayer. Benjamin also met with the pastor of his beloved church and placed in
his hands a discharge of mortgage for the new church and parsonage, stating that he couldn’t leave
the earth without doing this. He had paid the remaining amount of the mortgage with his own
The doctors at Elmira offered him little hope and told him that he would die soon. He accepted
this calmly but said that he wished to live. His entire family traveled to New York and was with
him when he died on December 26, 1864 at 3 o’clock in the afternoon, offering prayers and comfort.
He was only forty-five years old. He was so well-loved and respected in Ypsilanti that when the
train carrying his body home for burial arrived at the depot a few days later, a crowd was waiting
to welcome him home, including formal delegates from the city, friends, townspeople, and
representations of organizations and businesses.
The young Benjamin lay in state in the parlor of his beautiful home the next day from nine in the
morning until one in the afternoon and it was reported in his obituary in The Ypsilanti True
Democrat that there was “a constant throng of visitors to see the corpse. Dressed in
his business suit he looked natural as if he had quietly gone to sleep.” At one in the
afternoon the remains were then escorted to St. Luke’s Episcopalian Church on North Huron Street,
which he loved so well. The funeral sermon described him as a true Christian man who daily lived
his religious with honesty, generosity, and love for all men. From the church the long funeral
procession brought the body of Benjamin Follett back to his beloved River Street where it remains to
this day at Highland Cemetery, now surrounded by the remains of his loving wife Elvira and much of
Elvira was left to raise six children, which she did with the help of her aunt. Death visited
the River Street mansion again within the year when daughter Lucy died at the age of 18. Elvira’s
oldest daughter, Alice, married in May, 1865 and one by one, the Follett children grew and left
home. Elvira, often in the company of her mother, continued to be active in community endeavors.
She also was able to enjoy travel and adventure and in 1873, accompanied by her son, L.D. Follett,
went out west to visit her two sons, Nathan and Benjamin, who were living as pioneers on a ranch in
Fort Collins, Colorado. Elvira’s health was not good at this time, but she thought that the change
of climate might be helpful. While in Colorado, she ventured into the mountains for campouts of
three or four days with her sons and returned in good spirits believing that the adventure had much
improved her body and her spirits. Her letters to friends reflected her joy in anticipating trips
and also in returning from them.
In 1876, Elvira’s mother, Roccena Norris, died a painful death following a long illness, and
the next year, 1877, her aunt, Mrs. Blackmon, who had been a second mother to the Follett children
and lived with them, also died. Unfortunately Elvira’s health was on a decline and she spent less
and less time at her own beloved home, which she refused to move from, and more of it with her
children in Grand Rapids, Detroit, and even Kansas, but she returned to her home on River Street to
live out her last days.
Even though she was an invalid, suffering with pain, the last four years of her life were
blessed. Her children and grandchildren often came to stay with her, and her River Street mansion
again came alive with lively conversation and children’s laughter and games. She continued to
enjoy reading, learning, and reflecting on her well-lived life. Thinking that death was near, all
of her children were summoned to their childhood home on River Street in late summer, 1884. However
Elvira seemed to have rallied from the visit and they left back to their own homes. Shortly after
that, Elvira caught a chill and died on September 10, 1884. She was 63 years old. After a
well-attended viewing at the home and funeral at St. Luke’s, her brother Lyman so eloquently
stated “The weary, pain racked body was laid to rest beside that of the husband of her youth,
in beautiful ‘Highland Cemetery’, which now crowns the hill that overlooks the valley of the
Huron, and where in the month of June, 1828, she and her mother caught the first glimpse of the home
they afterwards came to know and love for almost half a century.” Elvira returned to River
Street to rest for eternity.
And what of the beautiful mansion that was once the crown jewel of Ypsilanti? Part of it still
remains, a shadow of the glory that it once was. The “gymnasium” of the Benjamin Follett estate
on River Street was purchased in 1861 by Charles Woodard and moved to 301 Grove Street. He
converted it to a residence and added a two story wing in 1863. The Woodard family lived in the
home for almost a century. Unfortunately, the home and property were on a decline when purchased in
1980 by Joseph Mattimoe and Henry Prebys who have lovingly restored, improved, and turned the homes
and gardens into another east side showplace. The barn had burned down, and after the death of
Elvira, the house and garden were untended. In 1904, Shelly Hutchinson, who had grown up across the
street from it, purchased the home and land to use for gardens to glorify the mansion that he was
having built on River Street between Forest and Oak Street.
Though the Follett mansion is gone, the legacy of Benjamin and Elvira Norris Follett lives on in
other structures - the Follett and Masonic Blocks are an integral part of Depot Town. Take a walk
down Cross Street in Depot Town and feel their presence in the love, vitality, and hope that this
generous couple bequeathed to Ypsilanti, Michigan.
(Jan Anschuetz is a long time member of the Ypsilanti Historical Society and a regular
contributor to the Gleanings.)
Photo 1: The Follett residence as featured in the Washtenaw County Plat Map publication in 1856
Photo 2: Mark Norris Follett (named for his grandfather) who died at six years old.
Photo 3: The Follett House c1870.
Photo 4: Nathan Follett
Photo 5: The Follett Residence in c1870.
Photo 6: The “gymnasium” of the Benjamin Follett estate on River Street was purchased in 1861
by Charles Woodard and moved to 301 Grove Street. He converted it to a residence and added a two
story wing in 1863.
Photo 7: East Cross Street looking west in c1859. The Follett Block is on the right side of the
Photo 8: Benjamin Follett.
Photo 9: (left to right) Mrs. Mark Norris, Mrs. Benjamin Follett, Lucy Uhl and Mrs. Ed. Uhl.